I’m sorry there haven’t been any updates to The Coven in a while. I trust that you can guess why. I will resume my regular update schedule very soon.
I’m sorry there haven’t been any updates to The Coven in a while. I trust that you can guess why. I will resume my regular update schedule very soon.
I reached out and touched the mirror.
In response to my touch, the colored lights shifted and coalesced into an array of different shapes and sigils against a light blue background. I tried touching the mirror again, and this time my finger brushed against one of the sigils- an elaborately scrolled letter R. The image on the mirror changed again, this time showing an unfamiliar room.
A white, overstuffed chair stood at the center of the room facing the mirror, and behind it was a beige sofa and a white wall covered in simple but colorful artwork. The art was drawn with bold lines and bold colors, depicting a girl in a floral dress, a bear holding an apple, and a ship with its white sail spread wide against a blue sky.
I looked behind me, and saw that the white room remained unaltered.
“I’m coming- hold on.” A young woman’s voice rang out from the mirror. “I’ll be right there.”
A few moments later, a woman dressed in nothing but a pair of loose breeches and a tight blue chemise ran into view, and threw herself into the overstuffed chair. She had been carrying a cup, which she stowed somewhere below the mirror’s frame, and then she brushed a lock of hair out of her eyes and blinked out at me with an expression of surprise that I thought must mirror my own.
She was a beautiful girl, with neat features, wide brown eyes, and hair of an unnaturally bright red hue, which fell in feathery layers to her shoulders. Her skin was so clear that it seemed to almost glow and her lips were such a deep red I thought they must have been painted with rouge.
The girl shook her hair out of her face, and seemed to regain her composure. “Um- hi. Who are you?”
My mouth went dry as I tried to think of how to respond. Was this girl friendly, or hostile? Could she help, or would she hurt me? I considered fleeing the room, but my legs would not move.
“My name is Raven,” she said in a gentler voice. “It’s ok- I won’t hurt you. I’m so far away that I couldn’t hurt you if I wanted. You’re only looking at a picture-”
“How far? Are you on another world? Are you on the red moon?” The words tumbled from my lips before I could think better of it.
“How do you know about that? Who are you?”
I swallowed hard, cursing myself for my foolishness. I felt as though I were trapped by both fear and ignorance, and I could not think of a useful or convincing lie.
“My name is Grace Ainsworth Frey; I am the wife of Lord Hope Uriel Frey,” I said, curtseying deeply.
“There’s no need to bow or anything,” the girl protested. She ducked her head as though in embarrassment and picked up her cup again.
“So, where is Hope?” she continued. “Sorry- I mean Lord Frey. I sometimes forget how formal you are down there.”
“He’s-” I hesitated. Hope was already in enough trouble with the inquisition- if this girl was a demon, could she make things worse for him? Would she curse him for his betrayal, as well?
“It’s ok,” Raven’s voice took on a more soothing cadence, as though she were speaking to a frightened child. “Just breathe. I won’t hurt you- I swear. Lord Frey is my friend.”
“If you are his friend, would you be willing to help him? If you can, I will take any oath, make any promise, do anything to appease your anger.”
“I’m not angry- why would I be? Tell me what happened to Lord Frey.”
“He’s been arrested,” I said. “He’s being held on charges of witchcraft.”
Raven put her cup down again with a loud clatter. “Holy crap. How did this happen? Shouldn’t Pius and Lux be in charge of the inquisition, now? I’ve been trying to contact Pius for days, but-”
“Father Pius is the one behind it. He said that Lord Frey violated coven law when I-”
“You didn’t reveal our secret, did you?”
“I didn’t. I made a promise never to tell. But I kept my discovery a secret from Pius because I was afraid of him.”
“I don’t blame you for that,” Raven said. She stood up and began to pace back and forth across the room.
“Crap- I can’t do anything from here, and there aren’t many of us on Terra that I can contact. What is that idiot doing?”
“Are you the demon with whom Lord Frey formed his contract?”
Raven stopped pacing and looked out of the mirror once more.
“How do you know so much? Even Lord Frey doesn’t know where I am.”
“I’m an astronomer; I was able to deduce your location.”
Raven smirked. “You know, Pius was worried about you, and now I understand why. The damage is already done, though.
“Listen, Lady Frey- you need to be careful of Pius. He’s more powerful than you know, and he’s cut himself off from his friends, which means he’s betrayed us, and we can’t predict what he will do next.”
“He’s already demonstrated his power to me,” I said, “but as long as he has my husband-”
“You don’t get it; he’s not an ordinary witch. He’s a demon, like me, only much, much stronger. If what you say is true, and he had Lord Frey arrested-”
“Not just Lord Frey- Father Pius had everyone in the coven arrested except for Brother Lux and Mrs. Auber.”
Raven put a hand to her forehead. “Damn. He wouldn’t have cut himself off from everyone unless he didn’t think he needed us anymore.”
“But why would he do such a thing?”
“I wish I knew. Lady Frey, the political situation on Terra is nothing compared to the chaos on the Red Moon. On Terra, you are living with the threat of war, but here war has been waging for centuries between the Angels and Demons. In fact, most of the problems on Terra can be traced to our war. We use the humans as our pawns, I’m sorry to say. I don’t think that Pius wants to join the Angels, because he’s never shown any sympathy to their cause, but I know he wants power. He might even try to take your world from the Gods.””
“Can he do it?”
“Who knows? He’s certainly strong enough to cause chaos. I think that you should lay low. Pius already had his eye on you, so whatever you do, don’t piss him off.”
“If Pius is as dangerous as you say, then I must try to fight him- not only to save my husband and his friends, but to stop him from seizing even more power. This is partially my fault. I must take responsibility.”
“Stop it,” Raven said. “I’ve been helping him from the beginning, so I’m the one who should take responsibility. I wanted to weaken the Gods’ power and loosen their grip on Terra, and I assumed that Pius had the same goals. You seem very brave, Lady Frey, but you need to let me and the other demons handle Pius. I swear that I’ll do what I can to stop him and save your husband.”
I did not trust her words, but all I could say was, “thank you.”
The combination of fatigue and fear had produced a strange state of mind. As I spoke to the girl through the magic mirror, a feat as strange as it was impossible, I felt as though I had drifted into a dream.
Wake up, Grace, I urged myself. Remember why you are here.
“I cannot destroy the mirror,” I said. “If the inquisitors find it, they may use it as evidence against my husband.”
Raven nodded. “I’ll deactivate it from this side. Have the inquisitors found anything else?”
“I don’t think so. Lord Frey’s library was destroyed.”
Raven sighed. “That’s something, at least. Thank you for telling me what happened, Lady Frey. I’ll contact you again if I can find a way.”
“But if you destroy the mirror…”
“There are other points of contact with Terra. But-” Raven paused and gave a small, sad smile. “If I can’t contact you again, tell Lord Frey that I’m sorry, and that it’s been an honor to work with him.”
I nodded. “Goodbye.”
And then the image in the mirror vanished, but I could not see my reflection. The mirror was now a lifeless piece of glass, as black as slate.
Had it all been a dream?
I walked back through the tunnel with only candlelight to guide me. The magic baubles
still hung overhead, but now they were useless glass balls that only reflected the weak light of my candle as I passed.
Speaking to a demon who dwelt on the red moon, learning that Father Pius was a demon, and using magic devices crafted by the demons themselves- how many more strange things would I encounter before I no longer trusted my own senses? Hope’s witchcraft had been difficult to accept at first, but Hope and his friends had eventually confirmed what I saw. Reality was something I could share with others. Now I was alone, and I was certain I had gone mad.
The more I tried to unravel the mysteries around me, the stranger and more mysterious the world appeared.
I paused to compose myself before ascending the ladder to the cottage. I knew that I must not let Brother Lux see that anything strange had occurred, but my resolve to hand him the Frey family writ was wavering.
Before Brother Lux had asked me to help him retrieve the writ, I had predicted that it would be able to save Hope’s life. Brother Lux and Father Pius were many steps ahead of me in the game, though, and I realized that the writ may have implications I hadn’t anticipated. However, Brother Lux already knew everything about the writ, so I was giving him no new information by handing it to him.
A new thought occurred to me; Raven had warned me not to underestimate Father Pius’s powers. Only the power of a God could break the High Priest’s seal, as far as I knew, but a demon’s power was something beyond my knowledge. If Father Pius could break the seal, he might destroy whatever protection the writ gave Hope.
But if he breaks the seal, it will save Celeste’s soul. Hope would gladly give his life for that.
I took a deep breath and ascended the ladder.
Brother Lux was sitting in a wicker chair by the window. The heavy curtains were pulled back, but Brother Lux was sitting in a shadow beside the patch of soft, pink morning light that filtered inside.
When he saw me, he stood. “Did you get the writ?”
“Yes.” I held it out to him.
Brother Lux stepped into the patch of light and snatched the paper from me. He examined it for so long that I could see the light grow brighter around him as the sun rose. He even tried to tear the corner of the page, as though trying to detect a forgery.
“Thank you, Lady Frey,” he finally said. He clutched the document to his chest and raised his eyes toward the ceiling. “I hope that you will soon know how much good you’ve done. Come- the sun is rising, and we must leave before we are spotted. Take the candle with you; I don’t want to leave any evidence we’ve been here.
Brother Lux carefully closed and locked the cellar door, rolled back the rug, and we departed.
Abbess Joy met us on the road as we approached del Sol. She took my hand and helped me down from the chaise so we could walk to the abbey together.
“You’re weary and half-frozen,” she said, rubbing my hands. “Please come rest, and promise me you won’t have any adventures for a long while.
“I promise,” I said, too weary to protest.
We walked past the cathedral just as the sisters exited from their morning prayers. Three veiled sisters accompanied by Mercy, Miss Taris, and Celeste, stepped onto our path.
“Aunt Grace! You came back,” Celeste cried.
“A promise is a promise,” I said.
“What in the world are you wearing, Lady Frey?” the second sister said, throwing back her veil.
“Lady Dupuy! You made it here safely.”
“I told you to call me Innocence,” she chided. “And yes, I’m safe. I’m glad that you’re here. When I heard what had happened-”
“Don’t speak of it,” the third veiled sister said in Sister Purity’s high, sweet voice.
“Well, I’m sorry for what happened,” Innocence said, and then smiled more cheerfully. “I found Purity, and here is Miss Taris, even. It looks like all of the ladies are safe, now.”
“Not all,” I said, remembering Lady Willoughby and Chastity. “I wish they were. I wish everyone were safe.”
“Please, Lady Frey,” Abbess Joy said gently. “Excuse us, but Lady Frey really must rest.”
“Of course.” Innocence put her veil back down. “I have to wear this veil if I’m to stay hidden, but I wanted to let you see I am well.”
The other sisters turned to go, but the first, whom I guessed was sister Jubilee, stepped forward.
“Thank you, Lady Frey. I’m glad you’re safe.”
“Leave her alone- she needs to sleep,” Mercy said. She stepped forward and took her quarterstaff from my hands. “Go rest, Lady Frey, and welcome back.”
Abbess Joy smiled, took my hand, and led me away from my friends.
Abbess Joy and I walked through the gently rolling dunes in silence. I stumbled once or twice from exhaustion, but each time Abbess Joy helped me back to my feet, and waited for me to regain my balance before we continued.
She led me up to the abbey, and we took a shortcut between two buildings and through the stately, white cloisters to the dormitory. Even so, the walk seemed miles further than it had the previous night. As I walked down the dormitory hallway, toward the cell where I’d stowed my things the night before, time almost seemed to slow.
When we finally arrived, I opened the door and approached the cot. I could not lie down, however. Something seemed, though. The bed was too small, and the room too empty. I did not have a hand to hold while I slept.
“Lady Frey? Are you alright?”
“He cannot-” I started to speak, but my voice broke, and I had to begin again. “He cannot sleep without me.”
And finally, too weary to stand any longer, I collapsed to my knees by the bed. Abbess Joy reached out to hold me as tears escaped from my eyes.
“Let yourself cry,” she soothed. “You’ve held your feelings inside for too long.”
A sob broke through, and I felt as though a dam burst in my heart. I wept and wept; I thought I would weep forever. My face grew slick with tears, and my throat was sore from sobbing, but still the weeping continued. Abbess Joy continued to hold me.
After a few minutes, my sobs subsided a little so that I could breathe, but then I saw Hope’s bruised and beaten face in my mind’s eye, and the sobs continued again.
Abbess Joy rocked me in her arms a little as though I were a child, and started to sing a gentle, hauntingly familiar tune.
Steady burn the evening stars,
Brilliant as the noonday sun,
Be we near or be we far,
We are one. We are one.
When I recognized the song, I was overcome by a fresh wave of tears. It was a song she had sung me as a child- the litany of peace. Abbess Joy’s holy magic failed to calm me, but within the tears, the song, and Abbess Joy’s tenderness, I felt something begin to knit and heal inside of me.
Steady fly the birds above,
Here, below, our worries cease,
Listen to my words of love:
Give us peace. Give us peace.
“Are you sure you want to do this?” Abbess Joy asked me for the third time.
I had first gone to the dormitory to see Celeste to bed. After the stories, songs, hugs, and promises I would return the next day, Celeste fell asleep. Then I’d gone to my own cell, where my trunk had already been stowed, to prepare for my journey.
Mercy, Abbess Joy, and even Sister Jubilee had followed me, and after I’d refused to tell them where Brother Lux and I were going, they’d crowded into my already cramped cell to try to dissuade me.
“I’m not sure about this, but I must act,” I said to Abbess Joy. I knelt beside the trunk, opened it, and started sifting through clothes.
“I have a better question,” Mercy said. “Have you gone mad?”
“Yes- I possibly have.” I removed one of Hope’s shirts and a woolen waistcoat.
“Why would you go with the man who imprisoned your husband on some mysterious adventure?”
“It may be a fool’s errand, but it may be my husband’s only salvation,” I said. “Given his current chances, this is a move I must make.”
“I can’t protect you if you leave del Sol,” Abbess Joy said quietly. “My magic is bound to this place. If I go into the world without the Gods’ blessings, I am powerless.”
I paused, clutching a pair of breeches. “Thank you, Abbess, but please don’t worry about me. Brother Lux and I are taking a back-road from the cathedral, in the opposite direction from where we met the bandits. As for Brother Lux- if he’d wanted to harm me personally, he’s already had ample opportunity to do so. We will return as soon as we can.”
“I think you should go, Lady Frey.”
Abbess Joy, Mercy and I turned to Sister Jubilee in surprise. I’d begun to see Sister Jubilee as an extension of Abbess Joy, and until now Sister Jubilee had followed her mistress in silence. But when Sister Jubilee spoke, it was in a warm, confident voice almost as surprising as the words themselves.
“You promised Celeste that you would fight to free Lord Frey. I’m glad those weren’t just pretty words.”
“I fail to see how this is any of your concern,” Mercy spat. Then she turned back to me. “Lady Frey, we should discuss this alone.”
“I don’t have time, Mercy. We can talk when I return.”
“There’s no point in talking after you return. At least let me go with you. I promised Lord Frey that I would protect you.”
“Stay here to fulfill your promise. Protect Celeste for him.”
Mercy groaned and left the room as I continued to dress. In a moment, she returned with her quarterstaff, which she thrust into my hands.
“At least take a weapon.”
“I don’t know how to use it,” I protested.
Mercy adjusted my hands, demonstrating the proper grip. “It’s simple- strike your enemy with it. Aim for the stomach, head, or knees.”
I nodded. “Thank you.”
“No- don’t thank me. I’d rather you didn’t go on any foolish adventures without at least a month’s worth of training- or a year at the rate you’ve been progressing.”
Abbess Joy stepped forward. “Celeste is safe here- I promise. Please reconsider taking Mercy with you.”
I sighed. “It’s not that I don’t trust you, but after everything that’s happened, it’s difficult to leave her again.”
Abbess Joy placed her hands over mine. “May the Gods bless you, Lady Frey. Please return unharmed.”
“I will,” I promised.
I found Brother Lux outside, readying a small, two-person chaise.
“Lady Frey, I hope you are ready to-” he turned and stopped speaking as soon as he saw me.
I was wearing Hope’s clothes- shirt, waistcoat, and breeches, with a wool greatcoat over them. The shirtsleeves had to be rolled back, and the breeches cuffed, but otherwise they fit well enough. I’d tied my hair back with a black ribbon in the dragoon style, completing the effect.
“I trust we won’t meet the bandits again, but they seemed most interested in kidnapping ladies. Hopefully, in the darkness, this will disguise me well enough.”
“And if it doesn’t?”
“Then I will be able to fight more easily than I would in crinolines and stays.”
We climbed into the chaise, and Brother Lux took the reins.
“I thought a small horsecart would attract less attention than a coach-and-four,” Brother Lux explained. “Plus, I dare not bring the coachman along. It will be very cold, I’m afraid.”
“I understand,” I said. “My husband’s coat is very warm.”
We set forth down the pink, moonlit road together. We rode in silence for a time, and then I spoke.
“I’m sorry to ask questions of such a personal nature,” I ventured, “but I am curious about the nature of your relationship with Father Pius.”
“Yes. How long have you been…”
“For a very long time,” Brother Lux said, “though not long enough. I hope we may have an eternity together.”
“You must share a very strong bond.”
“Our bond is unbreakable,” Brother Lux said. “We are united in our purpose. If you are looking for his weakness, you will not find it in me.”
“If that’s so, then you must know that he hates me, and why,” I said.
The road dipped down slightly, and the path twisted until we came upon a lush, marshy riverbank, where water glittered in the faint moonlight among the shadows of heavy trees. Soon afterward, we turned down a crossroad that ran parallel to the river.
Brother Lux sighed, and then spoke. “Pius doesn’t hate you personally, Lady Frey.”
“He does hate the Ancients,” I said, “and that is enough to affect his feelings toward me.”
“Yes,” Brother Lux admitted. “When did you discover your ancestry?”
“My father told me just before he left court,” I said.
“No wonder you were so shaken that night. It must have come as a great shock.”
“When did you and Father Pius find out?” I asked.
The horses hooves clattered as road grew harder and sloped sharply upward. Brother Lux and I began our ascent into the hill country.
“This river leads us into the valley,” Brother Lux explained. ‘To answer your question- Pius suspected your Ancient blood when we learned of your magical resistance. After he was coronated, he gained access to the breeding records and was able to confirm his suspicions.I didn’t believe him until he showed me your mother’s record. I should have- he has seen much of the world and its secrets.
“Even so, I found it difficult to believe that you don’t have a soul. I saw fear in your eyes the night you discovered us at the full moon. I heard you crying as I lead you back to the manor, though you’d tried to hide your tears and I’d pretended not to hear. I saw you blush at my brother’s advances, and I watched as the two of you fell in love. Father Pius calls all of this an imitation of life.”
“I saw my mother’s contract,” I said. “I tested the High Priest’s seal, and it was genuine. Plus, as Father Pius guessed, my magical resistance is evidence of my ancestry. Perhaps feelings can exist without the presence of a soul, or perhaps I have a soul, but it is different than yours. How can I explain any of it when I don’t even know what a soul really is, or what it does?”
“You love my brother enough to put yourself at risk; that is not an imitation.”
“I have no point of comparison. I know I feel love, but I can’t feel how you experience the same emotion. I only know that if the pain I feel now is only an imitation, then I couldn’t survive the agony of true pain.”
As I spoke, my fear and my longing for Hope flared to life again- like I’d been prodding an open wound. I fell silent and took a deep breath to steady myself.
The silence stretched on and on as we rode. Marshes gave way to rough grasses, and then the shadows of sharp stones all along the riverbank. Hills rose over the horizon before us.
The red moon was starting to dip a little lower in the sky. I gazed at it, tracing every well-known detail with my eyes, and my mind filled in the features I’d found with my telescope- light-colored mountainous regions near the white streaks known as chastity’s tears, and a dark, heart-shaped area toward the south. I could see the shadow of the moon’s full disk past the gibbous curve of light. The red moon truly was another world.
I should have studied the red moon more while I had my telescope, I thought. After all, it was a world closely tied to magic, and it was the closest world to my earth- a world that Mr. Filius had once called Terra. The Coven’s abilities were tied to the moon’s phases, and even the stolen book had hinted that the moon was connected to magic.
If the red moon really is a world like my own, I wondered, then what sort of creatures populate it? Is it populated by the demons themselves?
It was a fleeting thought- silly, even- but as soon as it crossed my mind, something clicked into place like the missing piece of a puzzle. I remembered a question I’d asked myself in Father Pius’s office- why had Father Pius really destroyed my treatise?
To hide the truth that Terra is one world among others.
Father Pius was the High Priest of a coven, and possibly the most powerful witch in the world. I realized that he must hold magic secrets unknown to the others, such as why the red moon controls magic, and where the demons they contract with dwell. If the new moon was a point of weakness, he might wish to hide it, and if he had contracted with a demon, he must be bound to protect its home.
My heart started to pound, and I looked away from the red moon to the dark scenery around me. My idea was mad, but it fit all of my evidence so well that I could not dismiss it. If it was true, it was the most dangerous secret I’d ever uncovered.
I turned my face away from Brother Lux, afraid he might see the light of discovery in my eyes.
When we reached the base of bluebell hill, Brother Lux stopped and tied the horse to a nearby tree. Then we ascended the hill on foot.
There were no bluebells growing on the hill, now. The slope was covered by a thin layer of frost, which glistened like fresh blood in the moonlight. The frost was so slick that I was obliged to brace myself with Mercy’s quarterstaff as I climbed.
When we reached the crest of the hill, Brother Lux led me down a shadowed path underneath the eaves of the cottage- the same path I’d walked the night I’d discovered the coven. He motioned for me to wait for him under the eaves as he went forward to unlock the door alone. Then he gestured for me to follow him inside, and I moved under the shadow of the eaves until I reached the door.
I went inside, shut the cottage door, and placed Mercy’s staff against the wall while Brother Lux rolled back a braided rug from over the cellar door. Then he took a key ring from his pocket and undid all of the locks along the door’s edge.
“As you can see,” Brother Lux said, opening the cellar door and gesturing to the door’s underside, “my brother has covered the wood in magic sigils. I’ve tried to remove them, but they don’t seem to be written in ordinary ink. While they remain, there’s no way into the tunnel.”
I looked carefully at the door’s underside, but even in the sparse pink moonlight that filtered through the muslin curtains, it was plain to see that the wood was unblemished. Underneath, I could see the rough wood ladder that led into the tunnel.
“Brother Lux, I’m growing tired of your games,” I said.
He looked up sharply. “Do you refuse to help me?”
“How can I help you? There’s nothing on the door. The ladder into the tunnel is intact, and though it’s too dark for me to see very far, there don’t seem to be any blockages.”
“What- you can actually see a tunnel?”
“Of course I can- it’s right here.”
“All I see is a flat stone floor underneath a trap door, Lady Frey.”
I sighed in frustration. “Watch me.”
I swung my legs onto the ladder and climbed down into the tunnel. Brother Lux cried out in astonishment and stumbled back, his eyes searching all around as though he could no longer see me.
“Just put your arm through- you will feel the ladder,” I said.
Brother Lux continued to stare, but did not reply.
I climbed back up, and Brother Lux stumbled backward again as I emerged from the tunnel.
“Lady Frey,” he said, straightening his robes as though to regain his composure, “please warn me the next time you decide to pass through a stone floor.”
“I spoke to you before I ascended, but you didn’t hear.”
Brother Lux crawled forward and placed his hand over the tunnel’s entrance, waving it back and forth as though brushing a flat surface.
“It’s all in your mind,” I said. I took his hand and tried to force it through the tunnel entrance, but his hand would not budge.
“The seal is very well done- it blocks light and sound, and it cannot be forced.”
I dropped Brother Lux’s hand and sat back. “I don’t think I can actually break the seal; it simply doesn’t affect me. I will have to go through the tunnel alone.”
Brother Lux nodded grimly. He went to the window and drew a heavy curtain across the muslin, and then went to the shelves that were built into the back wall. When he returned he was carrying a candle, carefully shielding its light with his hand.
“Do you know where to find the writ? Will you be alright?”
“I can find the writ; only time can tell if I will be alright.”
I climbed back into the tunnel and began the lonely walk to the hidden room.
I was shocked to find that, after a few steps, the tunnel flooded with light. I looked up and saw that the magic baubles that hung overhead had lit themselves, as though to welcome me.
A shiver ran down my spine. The last time I’d gone into the tunnel with Hope, he’d promised me that the demons could not hurt me. But, I thought, if their magic could react to my presence, then he might be wrong.
I took a deep breath and continued, undeterred.
My own fears were the only things that accosted me on my walk down the tunnel. The lights occasionally flickered, and my footsteps echoed through the cavern, but no demon appeared, and no one awaited me when I reached the white room.
The room had altered very little since the last time I’d seen it. It was still bare of architectural embellishment, and still sparsely furnished. The most prominent object in the room was the magic mirror, where colored light shifted and danced in mesmerizing patterns.
I had expected the room to be ice cold, but a rush of warm air greeted me as I stepped over the threshold, though I could see no hearth and no fire. I took off Hope’s coat and draped it over a white chair, and then placed the candlestick on the floor. Hope’s silver trunk, embossed with the strange circle, was still in the corner, but next to it was a new object; a black trunk embossed with the initials G.A.F.
Before Hope and I had left for St. Blanc, I’d asked Hope to find a secure place for my telescope, and he had secured it well, indeed.
I opened the silver trunk and found two documents, the writ of condemnation and the blood oath I’d made with Hope. I stuffed the blood oath into my pocket, thankful for Hope’s foresight in hiding it, and examined the writ.
The ink still glittered black and fresh against white parchment, and the High Priest’s seal remained intact. I hesitated for a moment. Though I had already agreed to help, it was proving difficult to take the writ back to Brother Lux now that I had it in my possession. What if he used it against Hope- to prove that Hope had every reason to defy the church?
But Brother Lux is a Frey, too, I thought. If the writ can be used against Hope, it can be used against Brother Lux.
Reason held little sway with me in my present state of mind. The anxiety that had been building as I’d walked through the tunnel alone had reached its peak, and now dangerous possibilities flared to life in my mind, refusing to be snuffed out.
What if I had destroyed Hope’s seal by coming into this cavern? What if the inquisitors bypassed Hope’s seal altogether, and dug their way in? The inquisitors, lacking my ancient blood, would at least be able to see the sigils Hope had drawn on the cellar door. If they knew that the sigils were magical in nature…
“Don’t give in to despair,” I told myself aloud. “Do what you can.”
I looked around me, wondering how I could hide or destroy evidence of magic in case the inquisitors did force their way in. My telescope, while not magic, was a heretical object, so I removed it from the black trunk and placed it in the silver one. If there was a magic seal on the silver trunk, the inquisitors might not be able to open it.
I looked up at the most damning object in the room- the magic mirror with its dancing lights. I hesitated, for it seemed a shame to destroy something so beautiful, but I knew it must be done.
I reached out and touched the mirror.
Abbess Joy and her attendants led our carriage to the end of the moonlit road, where the cathedral stood stark and white against the black sky.
“The abbey is behind the cathedral, near the dunes,” Abbess Joy said, pointing into the dark distance. “The path through the dunes is narrow, so we must go by foot.”
“I’ve never been as far as the abbey,” Brother Lux said. “Is the walk difficult? Miss Taris is unwell.”
“I’m well,” Miss Taris contradicted. Brother Lux had helped her out of the carriage, but as soon as she was on the ground she had snatched her hand back and stood on her own.
Mercy jumped down from the box and stood beside me, and coachman turned away from the conversation to tend to his horses. Abbess Joy gazed at our party with a calculating light in her bright eyes.
“I would usually call it an easy walk- pleasant, even, as there is a lovely view and a sea breeze that sweeps up from the bay. However, it’s dark now, and the wind is very cold. Sister Blessing,” she turned to the tallest of her attendants, who stepped forward. “Please help Miss Taris. Sister Love can lead the way.”
Miss Taris heaved a heavy sigh, but allowed Sister Blessing to take her arm while Sister Love lifted a lantern to light the way. Brother Lux and Mercy fell into step behind them, and Abbess Joy and I followed.
We walked on a gravel path around the side of the cathedral, past a row of stained glass that glittered on the cathedral wall. Behind the cathedral there was a small courtyard, where I could hear a fountain tinkling in the darkness. There were no lamps in the courtyard, but the gibbous moon lit the dying shrubs and dry grasses.
We passed through a creaking courtyard gate and onto a sandy path that wound through a tangle of grass and brambles. As we walked, there were fewer and fewer brambles and more and more sand, and soon the path took us between mounds of sand crowned in pink moonlight. Beyond the dunes I could see the churning, dark sea that seemed to stretch out forever.
“Have you ever seen the ocean?” Abbess Joy asked in a low voice.
Abbess Joy and I slowed our steps, allowing the party to go ahead of us a little as we talked.
“No- well, yes. I think I saw it, long ago, but it may have been a dream.”
“You did see it,” she whispered. “Try to remember.”
“It was warm,” I said. I pulled my pelisse tighter around me against the frigid salt air. “I was running my fingers through the sand. Someone was with me.”
I looked up to Abbess Joy, who was watching me intently through the darkness.
“I have many dim memories from my early childhood,” I said carefully. “I may need help to bring them into harmony with one another.”
Abbess Joy smiled and nodded. ”I will help in any way I can.”
We fell silent and quickened our steps to catch up to the others.
“The abbey is close,” Sister Love said, her voice slightly muffled by her veil. She pointed to a set of low buildings that were clustered together behind the dune’s soft shadows.
The path sloped back uphill, and soft sand gave way to gravel that crunched underfoot. The buildings jutted out at odd angles from each other, like sunrays that led to a central point.
“Sisters, please take Miss Taris and Miss Mercy to the dormitory so they can get settled. Lady Frey, Brother Lux, and I will meet you in the refectory soon.”
“I’m staying with Lady Frey until I’m certain she’s safe,” Mercy said firmly.
“Very well. Please follow me.”
The party separated, and Abbess Joy led Brother Lux, Mercy and me up a short set of steps to the first building in the starburst.
“This is the Abbot’s hall, and if you follow the buildings clockwise you will find the kitchen, refectory, library, dormitory, and infirmary. The calefactory is in the center. The work house and stables are at the pilgrim’s cloister on the other side of the cathedral.”
Abbess Joy opened the door to the first building, and then led us down a hallway lined with lamps that glared off of the black and white tiled floor. At the end of the hallway was a door, where Abbess Joy stopped and knocked.
In a few moments, a veiled sister opened the door.
“Good evening, Sister Jubilee,” Abbess Joy said. “Lady Frey and Brother Lux have arrived.”
The sister started back, and then turned her veiled face toward me in silence. After a few moments, she stood aside to let us in.
As soon as my feet hit the threshold, I saw Celeste. She was sitting on a stone hearth at the back of the room, clutching her golden-haired doll to her chest. She looked up, and when she saw me she dropped the doll to the ground and ran to me. I knelt down, and she threw herself into my waiting arms.
“Aunt Grace- you’re here at last,” she said, squeezing my neck with her skinny arms. “Miss Milton told me the most awful things. She said that Uncle Hope and Uncle Just and all of their friends have been taken away, just like Mother was. Soldiers came to Rowan Heights, and I had to go away. Miss Morton said that Uncle Hope would probably-”
Celeste let out a choked sob, and said nothing more.
“You’re safe, darling,” I said, holding her tighter. “I’m here, now. Listen, I spoke to your Uncle Hope just before I left.”
She sniffed and leaned back to look at me. “You saw him?”
“Yes, I did. He is strong, and we’re doing everything we can to free him.” I took a handkerchief from my pocket, removed Celeste’s spectacles, and dried her eyes. “He wanted me to tell you that he loves you very much, and that he wants you to be brave. Can you be brave for him?”
“Yes. I love him, too.” She pulled away from me and turned to Brother Lux. “Are you going to help, too? Can you tell Uncle Hope and Uncle Just that I love them?”
Brother Lux hesitated, shrinking a little from his niece’s innocent, pleading gaze. Then he smiled and nodded.
“Lady Frey means to send a letter back to Lord Frey. so if you wish to include letters to your Uncle and Godfather, then I will convey them all personally.”
“Thank you,” Celeste said with a small curtsey.
Brother Lux bowed in return, and then spun and quickly left the room.
Celeste gestured to me, and I cleaned closer. She cupped her hand over my ear and whispered. “I can be brave because I’ve just learned that miracles are for real.”
Celeste stood straight and put her finger to her lips before I could ask what she meant.
“Lady Grace,” she said. “I’m glad you are still wearing your spectacles.” She took her own spectacles from me and put them back on, and then turned to Sister Jubilee.
“I told you she would remember, didn’t I, Sister Jubilee?”
“I wouldn’t forget,” I said. “A promise is a promise.”
Celeste threw her arms around my neck, again. “If only Uncle Hope could have come with you! I miss him so much.”
Tears stung my eyes, and I blinked them away before Celeste could see. “He misses you too, darling,” I said thickly.
I held Celeste for a moment in silence, and then Abbess Joy stepped forward.
“Miss Celeste, I’m sure you must be tired and hungry. Let’s all go to the refectory together.”
Celeste nodded and took my hand, and then she turned and offered her other hand to Sister Jubilee. Sister Jubilee stepped forward at once and took her hand.
“I couldn’t go without her,” Celeste explained. “Sister Jubilee is like my guardian angel.”
A simple repast of bread, cheese, and vegetable stew awaited us in the refectory, which proved far more satisfying than the cakes and jellies I had eaten at the palace. For the first time in days, I had an appetite- possibly from the physical exertion of fighting the bandits.
The refectory was largely empty, since most of the sisters had already retired. Our small party sat at one end of a massive wood table that took up most of the room. There were fires blazing in the two great fireplaces set into the rough stone wall, filling the room with warmth and comfort.
Sister Love, Sister Blessing, and Abbess Joy removed their veils to eat. Sister Jubilee, who sat on the other side of Celeste, kept her veil on and refused all offers of food. Miss Taris barely touched her own food, though Abbess Joy pressed her.
“Just drink the broth, Miss Taris. It will help.”
“No- I just want to sleep,” Miss Taris said.
“You’ve had too much excitement today,” said Brother Lux, who had been awaiting us in the refectory when we’d arrived.“I wouldn’t advise that you take any tea- just water mixed with a little wine so you can sleep.”
“I’m glad to hear you speak like a physician,” Abbess Joy said. “I was under the impression that you had given up the vocation.”
“I will always be a healer,” Brother Lux replied. “But right now, the High Priest has another use for me.”
“And you would never refuse him?”
“No- never,” Brother Lux said resolutely.
“Please excuse me,” Miss Taris said, standing. “I shan’t have any more. Goodnight, and thank you, Abbess Joy.”
Miss Taris curtsied and turned to go, almost colliding with another sister on her way.
“I beg your pardon,” the sister said in a soft voice, and then bowed to Miss Taris as she departed. The sister turned to Abbess Joy and removed a folded paper from the sleeve of her robe.
“Abbess, we’ve received a message from Father Pius. It’s for Brother Lux. May I…”
“Of course,” Abbess Joy said.
The Sister turned to Brother Lux, bowed, and held out the paper, which Brother Lux took.
“Thank you,” he said.
“You’re welcome,” the Sister said.
Something in the sweet, high tone of the voice spurred my memory. “Lady St. Croix, is it you?”
“I am Sister Purity,” she corrected before departing.
Brother Lux broke the seal on his letter and read.
“Abbess, would it be possible for me to be quartered near Lady Frey and Miss Celeste?” Mercy asked.
“Certainly,” Abbess Joy said. “I’ve prepared the cells in the dormitory’s new wing for your arrival. There is plenty of room.”
“How did you know to prepare the rooms?” Mercy asked. “We didn’t know we would come until two days ago, and there was no time to send word ahead of us.”
“To be honest, I had prepared a place for Lady Frey when I learned she was going to St. Blanc.” Abbess Joy turned to me. “I know your father, Lady Frey, and I feared that, in his ambition, he would seek to exploit you in some way. I-”
Abbess Joy’s voice hitched, but she took a deep breath and smiled, regaining her composure.
“I’m glad you’ve found your way to del Sol, Lady Frey.”
“I can’t thank you enough,” I replied, “for helping us on the road, and for giving us a place here-”
“Please do not thank me. This is a sanctuary open to all who are troubled, and you- you must think of this as your home.”
“Lady Frey,” Brother Lux interrupted. “Before you settle here, I have a favor to ask.”
“A favor?” I repeated, taken aback.
“This is a delicate matter; may we discuss it in private?”
For a moment no one spoke. Celeste dropped her spoon and looked back and forth between the adults, as though sensing the tension.
Finally, Abbess Joy spoke. “Can it wait until morning?”
“I’m afraid not,” Brother Lux said. “This is of vital importance.”
“If Lady Frey agrees to speak with you, I will give you the use of my private study. I will be close by, however,” Abbess Joy added with a severe look at Brother Lux.
“Mercy, will you stay with Celeste? I won’t be long,” I said.
“Be careful,” Mercy said, and then she held out her hand to Celeste.
“Come Celeste- If you get ready for bed, I will tell you about the bandits we fought on the road.”
“Mercy! No,” I protested.
Celeste’s attention, however, was already captured. “Bandits? What bandits?”
“There were six of them, just up the road,” Mercy said. “Lady Grace fought two of them at once.”
“Don’t tease me. I’m too old to fall for silly stories,” Celeste said. She held her free hand out to Sister Jubilee, who took it and followed Celeste and Mercy from the table.
“It’s the truth…”
“Don’t worry,” Abbess Joy said gently as I watched the three of them go. “Celeste could not be in safer hands than Sister Jubilee’s. She has been my assistant for almost two years, and even before that I had intimate knowledge of her character.”
“I trust you,” I said.
Abbess Joy escorted Brother Lux and I back to the Abbott’s hall, to the same office where I’d been reunited with Celeste.
“I will wait here, outside the door,” she said with a warning glance toward Brother Lux.
“I’m sure I needn’t remind you of your obligation to remain neutral,” Brother Lux said, meeting her gaze.
“I have the right to protect my sanctuary and everyone within,” she replied.
Abbess Joy left the room and shut the door behind her. Brother Lux turned toward the door and raised his hand.
“Silence,” he said. Then he turned away from the door and paced toward the great stone fireplace.
“You need only touch the door to break my spell,” he said, warming his hands. Then he turned to me and took a packet of paper from inside his robes. “I need your help, Lady Frey. Our plans have hit a roadblock, and your assistance is vital to Lord Frey’s safety.”
“His safety?” I said incredulously.
“Yes. As an act of good faith, I will tell you two secrets before I ask my favor. First, the deductions you have made are correct- I do not intend for my brother to die. I won’t tell you how or why, but Father Pius and I are manipulating the trial.”
“This is madness,” I said. “If you wish him to live, then set him free.”
“Everything has already been set in motion, Lady Frey. Even so, everything Father Pius and I are doing is for the greater good. I don’t expect you to understand, but please believe that I love my brother, and I wouldn’t sentence him to death for anything.”
“How can I believe you, after what you’ve done?”
The papers in Brother Lux’s hands were tied with a leather strap, and Brother Lux’s fingers fumbled a bit as he untied the knot. He handed me a letter from the top of the stack.
“If I’m lying, then you may use this weapon to destroy me.”
I took the letter and opened it. It was written in an unfamiliar, spidery script.
“My Dearest Lux,” I read. “It has been too long since we’ve been alone together. I long to feel your arms around me, to feel your lips against mine, to feel your-”
My face grew hot, and I was unable to read the next words aloud.
“I am sorry to show a letter of such a personal nature to a Lady,” Brother Lux said, “but it is the best evidence to use against us.”
I skimmed the letter, and at the bottom I saw the signature.
My cheeks still burned, and for a time I didn’t know what to say. I had only skimmed the letter, but that was enough.
“You and Father Pius-”
“-are lovers, yes. We’re even more than lovers, truth be told.”
“But you are both men.”
Brother Lux put a hand to his face, trembling. He was silent for a moment, and then he let out a short bark of laughter, followed by another, and another. He dropped his hand, and I understood he had not been trembling at all, but shaking with laughter.
“How could you laugh at a time like this?” I demanded. “If you just came here to laugh at me, then I will go.”
“No wait- please. I don’t mean to jest. This is nervous laughter, more than anything. I had prepared myself for your disgust and condemnation. I was ready to counter your threats and negotiate our next move. I forgot how young you are, and how sheltered you have been.
“You see, Lady Frey, common sins are shouted down from the pulpit, but some sins are only whispered about behind closed doors, and never spoken of in polite company. My sin with Father Pius is one of the latter.”
“Who can explain the Gods’ laws?” Brother Lux said with a shrug. “They are absolute. The fact that I’ve broken my vows to take a lover is bad enough, but the fact that my lover is a man is a sin worthy of death.”
I folded the letter. “If your sin is so grave, then why did you give this to me? I could use this evidence to blackmail or destroy you.”
“That’s more like it,” Brother Lux said with a lopsided grin so reminiscent of Hope’s that I had to turn away. “I gave you this letter to force a stalemate. If you use this letter to remove Pius and I from power now, then the inquisition will kill your husband without so much as a trial, like they have acted under prior High Priests. If I fail and allow your husband to die, then you will have nothing to stop you from using that letter to destroy me.”
I closed my eyes to block out distractions, but it only reminded me of how tired and sore my eyes were. I was too exhausted to think clearly, but I knew Brother Lux wouldn’t grant me the luxury of a night’s sleep before we continued. Despite his gentleness, Brother Lux was proving to be as difficult an opponent as Father Pius.
“What do you want from me?” I asked.
“There is a document that my inquisitors were searching for at Rowan Heights- a document that might save your husband’s life- but they were unable to find it. I suspect that it may be hidden in a tunnel under bluebell hill, but it’s a tunnel the inquisitors must not find. Unfortunately, my brother placed a magic seal on the tunnel’s entrance, and I don’t know how to break it.”
“You want me to break the seal for you,” I said. “The document you’re searching for is the Frey writ of condemnation, isn’t it?”
“Yes. My brother told you about our curse?”
“He showed me the writ himself. He’d thought that I might be able to break the High Priest’s seal, but I couldn’t. I may not be able to break the seal on the tunnel.”
“You can- it’s not like the High Priest’s seal. It’s only an advanced magic sigil.”
“I need to think,” I said. I turned and began to pace the room.
“This must be done soon- before the inquisitors venture to the cottage. We must not be seen.”
I closed my eyes again and thought.
Father Pius’s love note might have been a forgery, and yet I had noticed before a strong affection between Father Pius and Brother Lux that seemed beyond friendship. I remembered that I had seen them dance together the night of the coven’s revelry.
“Show me where it is written that your love is worthy of death,” I said.
I turned back to Brother Lux, who nodded. He went to a heavy, giantwood bookcase that stood beside the fireplace and removed a large leather tome.
“Volume 2 of the unabridged Litany,” he said, handing me the book. “It’s in the book of natural order, cadence 3, verse 12.”
I opened the book, flipped to the verse, and read aloud.
Beyond man’s hubris are other sins,
Against the nature bound within,
Eros between women, between men,
The stain of death shall lie therein.
I closed the book. “If I go with you, then how long will we be away?”
“It’s only a few hours by carriage to the hill country from here. I know a shortcut that runs through the valley. If all goes well, we should be back by noon tomorrow.”
I sighed deeply, and then turned to hand the book back to Brother Lux.
“I have a bad habit of overestimating my own abilities, and I regret all of the clever plans I’ve made so far. But you have forced my hand. Please don’t make me regret helping you.”
Miss Taris came to my room at a quarter to six.
She was properly dressed in a blue silk gown. Her face was clean, her hair turned up modestly, and her eyes were clear behind her shining spectacles.
“I’m glad to see you’ve recovered so quickly,” I said.
“I’m very well, thank you,” she said. “I’m well enough to travel. Brother Lux has sent me to fetch you- he’s awaiting us at the carriage.”
“No one told us that you would be coming, Miss Taris,” Mercy said.
Miss Taris smiled. “I’ve just spoken with my father, and I was able to make him understand my feelings. He agreed to release me from my betrothal, and I am going to del Sol to contemplate taking orders.”
“This is a sudden development. I’m glad you were finally able to persuade your father to release you.”
Miss Taris only smiled and nodded in reply.
“Miss Taris is not going to del Sol to take orders,” Mercy said. “She’s going to del Sol to spy on us for Father Pius.”
“Father Pius is my trusted friend and advisor. I will inform him of everything that happens at del Sol, of course.”
Mercy met Miss Taris’s triumphant gaze, and then reached down, hoisting Hope’s trunk with one arm onto her shoulder.
Miss Taris took a step back in surprise, staring at the heavy trunk, which was effortlessly supported by Mercy’s slight frame.
“Well, I suppose I had better be careful around someone as powerful as you.”
I stepped between Mercy and Miss Taris before the tension could build any further. “Come- the carriage is waiting, and the sun will set, soon.”
“Very good,” Mercy whispered to me as we followed Miss Taris. “She is powerful, but as long as you refuse to show the feelings she forces on you, she will doubt herself. If she tries to make us feel fear again, look the fear in the face.”
I wished I really were strong enough to fight the Prince’s army, as I had said to Hope. If I were, Mercy and I could defeat the Inquisitors and the guards, and then and storm the dungeons, freeing everyone inside. But even if I were physically strong enough to fight an army, Father Pius would still be able to destroy me. Perhaps the Coven together had enough magical strength to fight Father Pius, but he had divided and conquered them all.
All I could do now was force my steps toward the carriage that would take me away from Hope.
“Celeste is already on her way to del Sol, Lady Frey,” Brother Lux said when I met him at the carriage door. “I’ve sent the Abbess word that you are both coming, and she welcomes your arrival.”
“That is impossible- how could you have sent a letter and received a response so quickly?”
Brother Lux didn’t reply. Instead, he helped Miss Taris into the carriage while Mercy climbed onto the box. Brother Lux turned back to me and offered his hand, but I waved away his help and climbed into the carriage on my own.
“The seats have been warmed, but it is a very cold evening,” Brother Lux said. “Here, Lady Frey. Take this blanket.”
I turned away from him without a word. A tear escaped and rolled down my cheek, and I dare not look back at him so he might see it.
“Brother Lux is going out of his way to be kind to you,” Miss Taris said.
I wiped my face. “Miss Taris, I don’t expect you to understand how I feel, and for your sake I hope you never understand.”
The carriage pulled away from the palace, and though we traveled the same road, the splendor that had greeted me on the way to St. Blanc was gone. The fairy trees that arched over the avenue were bare, their branches reaching out like skeletal fingers. The pond was covered in a thin layer of frost, and the swans had all flown away for the winter. All of the real flowers were dead.
The sun lingered just below the cloudline and over the horizon as we drove over the wide, open park, but by the time we reached the public road the sun had set, leaving only a faint twilight. The moon and stars mostly all veiled by clouds, and soon I was staring out at a sea of darkness.
I could hear Miss Taris and Brother Lux breathing softly as they slept behind me, but I could not rest. Hope’s bruised and battered face was always on my mind, and when I did not actively try to re-direct my thoughts, my head was filled with the gruesome descriptions I’d once read as a young girl of inquisition torture machines.
We reached the crossroad village well past midnight. No adventure awaited me in the village like it had the last time I’d stayed. We had a sparse repast in the common room, and then went upstairs to rest for a few hours.
Mercy and I watched the Inn door all night. She was convinced that someone in the village might know who I was, and she didn’t trust Brother Lux to protect us. It didn’t take much persuasion for me to keep watch with her.
Fatigue from my sleepless night caught up with me the next day, but I tried to force my sluggish mind to stay awake and review everything I knew about Father Pius and his plans. At times I would succumb to the temptation to close my eyes, and I would fall into a fitful sleep. I would dream up plans to defeat Father Pius- each plan more impossible than the last.
We stayed the next night in a cottage just off the road, where I stayed up and kept watch with Mercy again. Then it was another day’s ride before the spire of the Cathedral del Sol appeared over the horizon.
We’d been following a crooked road that wound back and forth through the lowlands. The road grew dustier and whiter, and as it did the sun sunk lower in the sky.
When the sun touched down on the western horizon, del Sol’s spire reflected the red light so fiercely it seemed to catch fire and I had to shield my eyes as we approached. The road continued to zigzag, so that the reflection sometimes flared across the right carriage window, and sometimes the left.
The sun set, and though the Spire still shone, it faded until I could look at it directly. It was almost perfectly straight, unembellished, and taller than any spire I’d ever seen- taller even than the spire on the great cathedral in town. It looked silver in the fading light, glinting as though it were made of metal.
The path before us was still crooked, but we we no longer sloping downward. Now we were winding through patches of grass that waved in the cold, salt-scented air. We rolled on and on, but the spire didn’t seem to draw nearer.
“There’s nowhere nearby to stop,” Brother Lux said, yawning as he roused himself, “but the cathedral is only a couple of hours away.”
After a few more minutes the spire grew dark, and the stars came out one by one in the cold, clear sky. I tried to rouse my tired mind and shake away the mad dreams I’d been indulging. I would soon be with Celeste, and she would need to be told what had happened calmly and gently. I would need to be in a state to make her feel safe.
I was considering what I would say to her when the carriage jerked to a halt.
I opened to carriage window and leaned out into the frigid wind see what had happened. The dark outline of the cathedral spire still stood in the distance, blotting out the stars. Just few feet ahead of us,however, there were six men in dark cloaks blocking the road.
Brother Lux opened his door and exited the carriage. “Good evening, travelers.”
One of the cloaked men stepped forward. “Good evening, Friar. We’ve come to relieve you of your burden.”
A few of the men laughed in reply, but the man who had spoken bowed cordially.
“We provide a public service, you see,” he said in a voice so low it came out almost like a hiss. “It’s a shame for so many pretty ladies to be locked away in that nunnery, so if you have any with you we will gladly take them.”
“We will gladly take any gold you have, as well,” a deep voiced brute barked from behind him.
“For heaven’s sake,” Mercy said, drawing her quarterstaff from behind the box. “If you’re bandits, just say so.”
Mercy jumped down from the box, quarterstaff spinning, and struck two blows before her feet hit the earth.
Two men fell and the other four rushed at Mercy, the largest one swinging an axe and the leader bearing a staff. Mercy dodged their blows but fell back against the force of their advance. The coachman took a flintlock from under the box and aimed it at the largest man, but then cursed loudly as the weapon jammed. He flung it aside and jumped down to flee.
Two men broke away from the fight with Mercy to pursue the coachman, but stopped when they saw Miss Taris and I through the coach window. One of the men wrenched the door open and grabbed Miss Taris, and this action- happening inches from where I sat- seemed to rouse me from my shock. I drew back my fist and hit Mercy’s attacker in the Jaw.
My hand shook with fear, and my strike had been weak. The man stumbled back out of the carriage, however, more from surprise than pain. I took the opportunity to jump down from the carriage, and then kicked the second man in the stomach as he reached for me.
This time my blow landed hard, and the second man stumbled back, clutching his stomach in pain. Blood pounded in my ears, my palms were starting to sweat despite the cold, but I followed up with a second blow without thinking.
In the heat of the moment, however, I’d forgotten about the first man, who grabbed me from behind. The man I’d just kicked took a wheezing breath and then rallied. I started to slip down out of the first man’s grasp, but I froze when I saw a flash of silver in the moonlight. The second man drew a dagger and pointed it toward my face.
“Not so feisty now, are you, girl?”
Before I could think of my next move, the man dropped his dagger and fell senseless to the ground. Mercy had appeared and hit him from behind with her quarterstaff. I sent my elbow into the first man’s stomach, and as I slipped down out of his grasp, Mercy hit him in the head with her quarterstaff, too.
“They are witches,” he groaned, clutching at his head as he ran away down the road.
“Really? Just because we can fight, we’re witches?” Mercy shook her head, turned to me, and helped me to my feet.
“Congratulations. You’ve survived your first battle.”
“That was a battle?” I said.
“It’s not as glorious as the stories, is it? A battle is really just an exaggerated brawl.”
I turned back to Miss Taris. “Are you alright?”
“I- I’m fine,” she said, though her face was flushed. “I can’t-”
“The attackers have fled,” Brother Lux said, returning with the discarded flintlock in his hand, “except for the ones you have rendered unconscious- and another over here, I see. We should leave before they awaken.”
“What about the coachman?” I asked.
“I can drive,” Mercy said.
“We should try to find him,” I argued. “He is not a young man, and the bandits might catch him.”
“Don’t worry. I saw him go through the bushes- there. We will catch up to him when we go around the next bend,” Mercy said.
“Are you certain? Brother Lux asked.
“Certain enough- I’m not going out of my way for a coward.”
“Drive, then,” Brother Lux, said. He climbed back into the carriage and I followed. Mercy climbed back onto the box, and the carriage moved forward again.
“Miss Taris, are you well? You look faint.” Brother Lux put his hand to Miss Taris’s forehead.
“That man- he was disgusting,” she said, and then blanched at the carriage’s sudden movement. “When he put his hands on me, I could feel what he wanted.”
“It’s alright, Miss Taris,” Brother Lux said. He took her trembling hands and rubbed them for warmth. “You are safe now.”
“No- they’re angry now,” Miss Taris said. “I should have used my powers to influence their feelings, but I froze. I should have fought back.”
“There’s nothing you could have done,” Brother Lux said.
“But Mercy fought back. Even Lady Frey fought back.” Miss Taris pulled away from Brother Lux and turned to me. “Where did you learn to do that?”
“Mercy has been teaching me,” I said. “I’m not very skilled, yet, but-”
The carriage lurched to a stop and, as Mercy had predicted, the coachman darted out from the bushes and jumped back onto the box. I could hear a low rumble of hooves in the distance.
“They’re angry- they’re coming back,” Miss Taris cried.
“They had friends nearby,” Mercy called from the box. “Hold on.”
The carriage lurched forward again, and I opened the carriage window to look back. I couldn’t see the horses yet, but I could see the road smoking behind us from the pounding hooves.
After the next bend, the road straightened, and the carriage gained speed as we headed straight for the cathedral. I looked back again, and I could see the horses and riders outlined in crimson moonlight. They were quickly gaining on us.
“Brother Lux- do you still have the pistol?” I asked.
He fumbled in his cloak. “I have it, but I’m afraid I can’t use it.”
“Please try,” I said.
He raised the weapon toward the window, but his hands trembled violently.
“Here- I will try,” I said.
Brother Lux held out the weapon, but then drew it back hesitantly.
“Please, trust her,” Miss Taris pleaded. “We are all in danger.”
Brother Lux handed me the weapon.
I leaned out the window and saw the riders hot on our heels. I had no time to be afraid- I took a deep breath and held the gun the way I’d seen my father hold one when he shot. I cocked the gun and raised it, bracing my shooting hand with the other and aiming the weapon toward the head rider.
As soon as I squeezed the trigger, both the carriage and the riders behind us clattered to a halt. The motion jostled my arm, and the shot rang out into the grasses beside the road.
An eerie silence fell over everything. Even the horses quieted, and the breeze stilled. I looked forward and saw three robed figures standing on the road ahead. Despite the crimson moonlight, their robes shone a spotless white and their faces were shrouded in white veils.
The middle figure stepped forward, clutching a staff in their right hand. The figure raised the staff, and Miss Taris and Brother Lux both gasped in unison. The horses behind us reared back and, as though they’d been spooked by a bolt of lightning, turned and galloped away.
The three robed figures walked forward, approaching the carriage. The figure with the staff reached out and settled the frightened horses, and then came to the carriage door.
Unsure of what else to do, I opened the door.
The veiled figure placed their staff against the carriage door and then threw back their veil, revealing a familiar, gentle face crowned with golden hair.
Abbess Joy came closer, and then reached out and took me into her arms.
“You’re safe now,” she said. “Welcome to del Sol.”
Anger rose like bile in my throat when I saw what the inquisitors had done to Hope.
Hope’s long, dark hair had been shorn away to the scalp, his porcelain skin was mottled with dark bruises, and his warm brown eyes were blindfolded. He was sitting in a sackcloth robe on a wooden stool, but when the cell door opened he stood and stumbled forward, reaching out blindly with bound hands.
I ran to him and took his outstretched hands. “I am here.”
“Grace!” He clutched my hands. “Brother, please unbind me. You know I won’t try anything foolish while she is here. Let me see her- let me hold her- one last time.”
Brother Lux cast a sidelong glance toward me, and then unwound the cloth from Hope’s eyes.
“I won’t unbind your hands, but I will let you see her,” Brother Lux said. “If you try to hypnotize me, my bond with Father Pius will break the spell- the same as last time.”
Brother Lux’s casual admission of his betrayal- that he had brought knowledge of the blood oath to Father Pius- inspired a fresh wave of anger, and for one mad moment, my brain hatched a plan worthy of a storybook. Hope and I could overpower Brother Lux together, steal his clothes, and Hope would escape disguised as his brother. Unfortunately, Hope had been too thoroughly marred to pass as Brother Lux, now.
It was then that I remembered Father Pius’s threat, “…a strong and clever mage can use your resistance against you.” Brother Lux had the ability to heal, so it was possible he could make my body destroy itself if he turned his power against me.
I didn’t know how strong a mage Brother Lux was, or if Father Pius had told him my weakness, but I wasn’t foolish enough to take the risk.
When the bandages were removed, I could see that Hope’s right eye was blackened and swollen. He blinked at me, squinting as though he were trying to look at the sun.
“Hope- I’m sorry,” I said, holding his hands close to my heart. “I pressured you to keep my silence when we took the blood oath. I never dreamed the consequences.”
“You couldn’t have known,” Hope said quickly. “I’m the one to blame. I didn’t consider the laws, and worse, I didn’t put my trust in the right people. I will pay for my foolishness and my crimes.”
Brother Lux walked behind Hope and gave me a significant nod.
“I was told that you will have a trial,” I said. “You must try to fight the charges, if not for your own sake, then for Celeste’s.”
Hope looked down at our entwined hands. “Even if I weren’t guilty, witchcraft trials are a farce. My fate has been decided.”
“What evidence do they have against you?”
“I- I don’t know. They haven’t found anything at Rowan Heights, yet. The Library burned, but the inquisitors are still searching the rest of the estate.” Hope shut his eyes, as though trying to remember. “Lux- you told me that Mrs. Auber made the formal accusation, didn’t you?”
“That’s right,” Brother Lux said slowly. “Mrs. Auber provided one piece of material evidence- a blood oath entered into by you, Captain Goode, Lord and Lady Willoughby, and Miss Chastity. The oath states your intent to murder High Priest Sauris and Prince Hadrian as vengeance for Prudence Goode’s death, and as vengeance for the Frey and Goode family curses. The document states that you intend to use any arts, magical or mundane, to achieve your goal.
“In addition to this, Mrs. Auber is willing to testify that she personally witnessed multiple acts of witchcraft.”
“That’s odd,” Hope said. “I don’t recall ever taking such an oath.”
“Then the document is false, “ I said quickly. “There must be a way to prove that it’s a forgery. I’m willing to provide samples of your handwriting. Perhaps I could hire someone to examine the document while I am gone.”
“Gone?” Hope drew me closer to him, and I embraced him tightly.
“Father Pius is sending me away, but I’m going to Celeste.”
“You are? Will you keep her safe?”
“I swear that I will protect her. I’ve been working in secret- growing stronger in both mind and body. I will fight the whole army, if it will keep her safe.”
Hope cut me off with a kiss deeper and fiercer than any we’d shared before. Even though our bodies were pressed together, I felt as though I couldn’t get close enough.
Hope broke the kiss with a gasp and leaned back to look at me. He reached up and tangled his bound hands in my curls. “If you’re willing to fight, then I can’t do any less.”
Hope leaned down to kiss me again, but Brother Lux pulled him away.
“It’s time for Lady Frey to leave,” Brother Lux said.
“Give us a little more time together, please,” Hope said, turning to his brother.
“No,” Brother Lux said, his usually warm voice hardening like ice. “I told you that you must suffer the consequences of your actions, and that begins now.”
“Hope-” I took his face in my hands and turned him back to face me. “I’m going to Celeste. I promise that when we’re safely together, I’ll contrive some way to send word to you.”
“I love you,” he said. “Tell Celeste that I love her. Tell her to be strong.”
“I will. I wish I had something more to give you than a promise. You already have my love.”
“That’s enough,” Hope said.
Hope continued to look into my eyes until Brother Lux tied the blindfold back into place.
Brother Lux was silent as he led me out of the dungeon, so I was able to count my steps- re-tracing the mental map I’d made of the tunnels and filling in the gaps in my memory. I listened carefully to the way our footsteps echoed, gleaning an idea of the tunnel’s size. The tunnel’s draft remained at our backs as we ascended.
I continued to concentrate, and ignored my tears as they soaked into the blindfold. A little flame had been kindled inside of me, and it was growing stronger with each step, keeping despair at bay. Brother Lux’s look of pity as he took off my blindfold, the hisses and whispers of the courtiers when we ascended back into the cathedral, and the knowledge that I was being delivered to my greatest enemy only acted as fuel for the flame.
I imagined I could feel the same flame that had burned in Hope when he had committed desperate acts to protect his loved ones. The alchemy of Hope’s love had changed me.
I could hear muffled voices through Father Pius’s door as we approached, but as usual, Brother Lux opened the door without knocking. Mercy was inside, standing in front of Father Pius’s desk with her arms folded.
“I find it insulting that you would even ask me,” she was saying. “I can tell when I’m not wanted; do you think I’m a fool?”
“You should be grateful that I’m still giving you this chance,” Father Pius replied with a look so fierce that I would have shrunk back. Mercy only lifted her chin higher.
“I am grateful,” Mercy said. “I’m so grateful that if you release Lord Frey with a full pardon, and make a public apology, I might consider forgiving you.”
Father Pius blinked as though in astonishment, but did not reply. Brother Lux held a hand to his mouth and gave a strangled cough.
Mercy turned toward us and dropped her stance.
“Lady Frey- did you see Lord Frey? Is he alright?”
“He’s been beaten,” I said. “He has not been tortured, yet.”
“I understand that he,” Mercy nodded toward Father Pius, ”is sending you into exile.”
“I believe that is his intention.”
“When we came to St. Blanc, Lord Frey made me promise that I would protect you if anything happened to him. So when are we going into exile? Where are we going?”
I blinked away the tears that welled up at this simple show of loyalty. “Thank you, Mercy.”
“Don’t thank me. I’m only following orders.”
“You may not be one of us, but you are still bound to secrecy, Miss Mercy. If you leave my service to follow Lady Frey, you must remain in exile with her,” Father Pius said.
“Leave your service?” Mercy turned sharply back to Father Pius. “I was never your servant to begin with.”
“So be it,” Father Pius said. He turned back to me.
“I have been trying to decide where to send you. You cannot return to Rowan Heights. The estate is still being searched by the inquisitors, and they wouldn’t welcome your interference. Celeste’s grandmother lives in a townhouse in the city- a place that is impossible to secure. Even though he’s under control, I hesitate to send you to your father’s estate-”
“I’ve broken relations with my father, anyway,” I said.
I took a moment to consider my situation, and Mr. Filius’s words came back to my mind. “All roads lead to del Sol.”
Can I trust Abbess Joy? I wondered. She is in league with the oculist guild, but she did test my magic resistance for my father’s benefit. I don’t know where her loyalties truly lie.
But my old memories of the Abbess returned at once, bringing that safe, maternal feeling that overrode all of my doubts.
“I would prefer to go into seclusion at del Sol,” I said.
“Those who seek sanctuary at del Sol are expected to work for their bread,” Father Pius scoffed. “When have you ever done a day’s labor?”
“Keeping Lady Frey at del Sol would probably be best,” Brother Lux suggested. “It’s well-protected. She could not interfere with our plans, and no one could interfere with her.”
Father Pius placed his hands on his desk and leaned down, closing his eyes. “I want to preserve del Sol and its Abbess, so I suppose that it will be convenient to keep Lady Frey and Miss Goode there, as well.”
I turned to Mercy. “Would del Sol be acceptable to you?”
“Then it’s settled,” Father Pius said. “I’ve dealt with you enough today, Lady Frey. Gather your things, and Brother Lux will call for you the carriage this afternoon. He can take you to del Sol on his way back to Rowan Heights.”
As soon as Mercy and I were left alone in my rooms, I took the nearest sheet of paper and wrote down the mental map I’d made of the dungeon tunnels, annotating the number of steps I’d counted at each turn. I wrote as quickly as I could, before the memories could fade any more, while Mercy watched in silence.
I reviewed the map for any errors, and Mercy spoke. “Lady Frey, we don’t have much time. We need to destroy anything that might implicate Lord Frey and choose what to take with us- we won’t be able to take much.
“I’m sorry- I needed to put this on paper before I forgot. I’m finished; this is as accurate as I could make it, under the circumstances. If you will go through Lord Frey’s other things, I will pack whatever I can into this trunk-” I gestured to the trunk with the hidden compartment.
Mercy nodded and left to search the room while I opened the trunk’s compartment and stowed the map inside. Then I closed the compartment, carefully replaced the trunk’s lining, and filled the rest of the trunk with the warmest, most serviceable clothes I could find. I packed Hope’s clothes as well as my own, so he would have something if he were freed or rescued.
Mercy stoked the fire, feeding letters and books into the flames. “He was careful, so there’s not much,” she said, “but some of his letters contain murmurings against the Prince and church, and some of his books were written by abolitionists. It’s best to be rid of anything that would look bad.”
“We can keep his letters to Celeste, and we will need his bank book if the inquisition leaves anything of his property. Everything else should be destroyed.”
Mercy nodded and stoked the fire further. “I’m glad it’s cold today; a large blaze is not out of place. I will help you finish packing when I’m done. Leave all of your silks and fine things behind-take only what will be useful. I suppose you may keep the necklace Lord Frey gave you, but wear it under your clothes. How much pin money do you have?”
“I have fifty gold coins in my purse- enough to get us to del Sol and to give a donation when we arrive.”
Mercy’s eyes went wide. “More than enough, I should say. Here are some clean handkerchiefs, a tinderbox, a ball of twine, and some of your sewing things. Don’t look at me like that; I don’t expect you to do embroidery, but this will be useful. Also,here is Lord Frey’s pocket knife. He only ever carried it when he went hunting, but you should keep it with you.”
She stuffed the other things into my valise and handed me the mother-of-pearl handled knife.
“We don’t want to overfill your valise. Is there anything else you can think of?”
“I will change into my traveling clothes in the Pavilion, so I can leave these clothes there, along with this ridiculous pannier. Other than that-”
I turned to my almost empty jewel-case, retrieved my fake spectacles, and put them on.
“I will not say that I am ready to leave, but I can’t think of anything else.”
I kept my head up as I walked behind Father Pius, determined not to show him my fear. I could hear courtiers hiss as I went past, but I did not acknowledge them.
“Word travels quickly at St. Blanc,” Father Pius remarked, “but the courtiers are fickle. I think you’ll regain popularity soon enough.”
I ignored his taunt, but quickened my pace to keep up with his long strides.
Father Pius led me up the cathedral steps and into his office. When we arrived, I saw that Miss Taris was seated by the hearth near a crackling fire, holding herself and shivering.
She was still dressed in her peasant’s clothes from the previous night, and her spectacles lay on the small table beside her. Even though she was shivering, her forehead was beaded with sweat, and her long hair stuck to her face in wet ropes.
“Miss Taris,” Father Pius said softly. The sneer on his face melted away, replaced by a look of concern. “You are cold.”
“I’m alright,” Miss Taris protested, though she allowed Father Pius to place his white cloak over her shoulders. “You were right- it is easier when I don’t fight the sensation.”
“Yes- just relax. The pain won’t last long, and soon you’ll be able to rest.” Father Pius wiped the sweat away from Miss Taris’s face, and then turned to me.
“Do not touch Miss Taris. Sit here- away from her.” He gestured to a chair in front of his desk.
Miss Taris looked up at me, still clutching the cloak around her shoulders.
“Something is wrong,” she said. “My power is growing, but I still can’t feel Lady Frey.”
“Take no notice of Lady Frey. You might as well try to discern the feelings of this table lamp,” Father Pius said, taking his own seat. “She is not human; she is an abomination.”
Father Pius spared a glance in my direction before looking back to Miss Taris. In that moment, I realized that he knew I was an ancient, and he hated me for it.
As frightened as I was, I took a deep breath and made my move.
“If you really know what I am, then you must know that the blood oath doesn’t bind me. If I chose, I could tell everyone your part in this. I have enough evidence to-”
My words cut off as my lungs squeezed painfully. I couldn’t draw breath, as though my chest were being crushed by an iron vice.
“You have no evidence,” Father Pius said coolly. “What is wrong? Can’t you breathe?”
I couldn’t even choke out a reply.
“I’m compelling you to breathe, but your body is fighting me. You want to obey me, but your will means nothing. You aren’t free- just powerless.”
He smiled down on me as I struggled, and after a time flicked his hand. At his gesture, the vice seemed to fall away and I fell forward, gasping for air.
“A weak mage might not be able to reach you, but a strong and clever mage can use your resistance against you. Even Lord Frey, had he really tried, could have left you brain damaged.”
I kept my eyes on the wood grain of his desk, coughing and trying to take one deep breath after another. Father Pius reached out and grabbed my face with one hand, digging his fingernails into my cheek as he forced me to look up at him. He leaned so close to me that his dark eyes seemed to engulf me.
“If it weren’t for certain promises I’ve made, you would already be dead. Never threaten me again.”
He let go of me and I fell forward.
“I had to at least try- for Hope’s sake,” I said.
“You can make things worse for him, if you keep trying,” Father Pius said. He took a quill and paper from his desk, and continued to speak as he began some work. “In fact, I had meant to thank you. If not for your assistance, I wouldn’t have had the opportunity to arrest Lord Frey and the others.”
A feeling of dread washed over me. “What do you mean?”
Father Pius smiled. “Perhaps Lord Frey never told you, but when he took the blood oath and swore to keep your secrets, instead of bringing you to me, it was a violation of our coven’s laws. Everyone who willingly submitted to Lord Frey’s hypnosis, except for Brother Lux, was complicit in this violation. Brother Lux was able to bring the violation to my attention.”
“I-I’m sorry. I didn’t know. Please- it’s my fault; punish me instead.”
“How quickly you go from threats to pleas,” Father Pius said smoothly, “but I have no reason to punish you. You were never bound by our laws, and you’ve helped my cause immensely. You gave Lord Frey the opportunity to put the Prince under my power, and now the coven is out of my way. To thank you, I will allow you to go into seclusion unharmed.”
A thrill of horror ran through me- I had done this- but I didn’t have the luxury to indulge in self-pity. Hope was imprisoned, I was at the mercy of my enemy, and I needed time to think.
I closed my eyes, trying to block out the scratching of Father Pius’s quill, but soon another sound distracted me.
“Oh!” Miss Taris let out a strangled cry, and then went silent again.
“Relax, Miss Taris,” Father Pius said. “Think of something else.”
“Do you think I might help?” I said.
“This isn’t her curse,” Father Pius said quickly. “That will come later. She’s just formed a contract, and her powers are growing rapidly. It’s a painful process, but it will pass. If you go near her, you might interfere.”
“Miss Taris, do you still want this?” I asked.
“Then tell me something to take your mind off the pain. I know you like to read; why don’t you tell me about your favorite book?”
“Why would you help me?” she asked.
“There needn’t be a reason,” I said, “though Lord Aston suggests our altruistic impulses stem from a desire to live in a society where others will behave altruistically toward us. Have you read Lord Aston?”
“Yes, but I don’t agree.”
“Why not?” I asked.
Miss Taris took and deep breath and began to explain her reasons. I argued a few of her finer points, nodded in agreement when appropriate, and did what I could to keep her talking as I half-listened. All the while, another part of my mind was racing.
What do I know, and what do I need to know? I wondered
First, I know that Father Pius isn’t afraid of me at all, even though I know that he is a heretic and a witch. He’s confident that I can’t expose him, and he can kill me before I even try.
But, I thought, if that is the case, then why did he promise to keep me alive? He could kill me without consequence. Everyone at court seems to think I’m a witch, already.
I realized that it would have been easy for the inquisition to kill Hope at the first sign of resistance, but Brother Lux had given Hope the opportunity to surrender and discuss the evidence against him. Father Pius and Brother Lux wanted to imprison the coven, but they wanted them alive for now.
A faint light of hope broke through my dark thoughts. If there really were a trial, then Hope, and perhaps Captain Goode, might be spared since they had produced no male heirs. Nothing but the power of a God could break the High Priest’s seal, so it might override the inquisition’s judgement.
Father Pius knew about the Frey and Goode family curses, so he would have taken them into account. This realization brought me to the second point of importance.
Second, I know that High Priest Pius premeditated his coven’s imprisonment. He’s admitted to me that the blood oath gave him an excuse under coven law to arrest those he’d wanted out of his way. Why would he do so, instead of continuing to use their powers to his ends? Why risk exposing himself when they were tortured, or when they went to trial?
Father Pius’s true goals must be in conflict with the coven’s goals.
“…and so people follow their baser instincts. We are all ultimately selfish,” Miss Taris was saying.
“Perhaps, but cooperation provides us all with long-term advantages, which was Aston’s main argument,” I countered almost automatically.
“You haven’t taken into account-”
“It isn’t your place to judge morality,” Father Pius interrupted. “It’s better to look after your own interests during your short time on this earth. Men with more knowledge and experience than you will solve the larger questions.”
Something about Father Pius’s tone struck me with a new thought.
Did Father Pius really burn my treatise to guard his reputation? If not, then why did he?
I wasn’t able to contemplate this idea any further before the office door opened, and Brother Lux stepped through.
“You are weary,” Father Pius said, looking up at Brother Lux. “I hope your brother didn’t cause you any trouble.”
“No- he is cooperating,” Brother Lux replied. As he spoke, I noticed that his face was drawn, and his eyes bloodshot. “I came here to ask a favor on his behalf. He wants to see Lady Frey.”
“Are you sure that is wise?” Father Pius said.
“I wouldn’t ask you unless I thought it was absolutely necessary,” Brother Lux said.
Father Pius leaned back in his chair and pinched the bridge of his nose. “I don’t mean to question your judgement,” he said quietly. “Do what you need to do, and bring Lady Frey back afterward.”
“Of course.” Brother Lux turned to me and stretched out his hand. “Come with me, Lady Frey. Don’t be afraid.”
I went with him, but did not take his hand.
Brother Lux led me down a winding staircase past the main sanctuary and into a cramped cellar. At the back of the cellar there was an iron grate, beyond which I could see a tunnel lit with flickering torches.
“Lord Frey’s cell is down there,” Brother Lux said, pointing into the tunnel. He took a square of black cloth from his robes. “I’m sorry to ask this, but the inquisition requires that all visitors be led into the tunnels blindfolded.”
I looked down at the blindfold, and then back up at Brother Lux’s bloodshot eyes.
“Please trust me, Lady.”
“I have no reason to trust you,” I said, “but if you wanted to hurt me, you wouldn’t need to take me into a tunnel.”
I allowed Brother Lux to tie the blindfold over my eyes, and then waited alone in darkness as I listened to Brother Lux’s footsteps. Once the Iron grate creaked open, Brother Lux took my hand and led me forward.
I ignored the feeling of his hand- long-fingered and smooth, just like Hope’s- and concentrated on the path. We were moving in a straight line, and the stone surface under our feet was smooth. There was a cold draft of wind on my face, which had a damp, earthy scent, and I surmised that we would be moving further underground.
“Lady, I have a question to ask you before we descend, and I need you to answer honestly. Do you love my brother?”
“Why would you care about our feelings, now?” I asked. My cold words echoed around the empty cave.
“If you love him, Lady, then it’s vital that you tell him- show him– that you do. I cannot tell you why.”
“I do love him,” I said, “and if you won’t tell me why that’s important, then I will guess.”
“Yes. You want to give him hope so he will be able to better withstand torture. Am I right?”
Brother Lux remained silent.
“But you aren’t trying to protect yourself- if Hope gave your name to the inquisition, it would look like a desperate move, and no one would believe him. No- you want him to live long enough to stand trial. I don’t know why, but you’re playing a dangerous game with my husband’s life.”
Some time during the course of the conversation, our steps had begun to curve to the right, though the draft always hit my face. Now Brother Lux stopped, and spun me as though we’d reached a branch in the tunnel. I felt no cross-breeze, however, and when he stopped me, the draft hit my face again.
Keep going forward at the first branch, I thought.
“Lady Frey, I don’t want to give you false hope, but please give him something to live for. He’s been saying some worrying things, and I need him to fight.”
“Even if I didn’t love him, he has Celeste. He will never give up while she’s alive. Will you take me to her, after I’ve seen Hope?”
“Yes. Promise him that you will care for her.”
“I will. Where is she now?”
“She is with her governess, awaiting word of our arrangements. Don’t worry; I’ve assured my niece’s safety.”
After a few more steps, we came to a staircase. I took both of Brother Lux’s hands and silently counted the steps as we descended in a spiral.
“Take your time, my Lady. We are almost there. I need to warn you about my brother’s appearance. He’s been…”
“You have tortured him already, haven’t you?”
“One of the inquisitors beat him. He hasn’t been harmed, though- just bruised.”
My feet hit the final step, and then Brother Lux led me to the right across a flat stone floor. He let go of my hands, and I could hear a door close behind me. Then my blindfold loosened and fell away. There was only a little lamplight, but it burned my eyes as I gazed blearily at the grated cells, which stood in a row before me.
“He is waiting for you in the first cell,” Brother Lux said.